The image of a wooden gun is meant to illuminate thoreaus point about the weakness of the government, as well as its fraudulent nature. A morally good agent is one who generally does what he believes he ought to do. It helped to professionalize philosophy as an academic discipline in the united states by publishing philosophers such as lewis white beck, john dewey, gottlob frege, hansgeorg gadamer, sidney hook, c. Civil disobedience has a long tradition in our country. As a result, thoreau hints to his readers that they should begin to question why. The moral and political importance of this point is explained in section 1, and two theoretical lessons are drawn. This disambiguation page lists articles associated with the title carl cohen. An example of this would be the differentiation between the ku klux klans. By putting civil in his title, thoreau may be trying to qualify that any disobedience should be nonviolence. Conscience, tactics, and the law university of michigan faculty reprints cohen, carl on. Civil disobedience stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. A venture in philosophical skepticism whose only practical effect might be to dissuade an isolated individual from civil disobedience on the basis of uncertainty. According to thoreau, what is the very best kind of government. Historic instances of civil disobedience are briefly noted.
But this definition also excludes disobedience by a wide range of groups, from labor activists to hunt. Carl cohen author of communism, fascism, and democracy. Civil disobedience is a form of not obeying the law as a protest against the laws that do not have any common sense and prevent people from having a comfortable life and freedom. The book was published in multiple languages including english, consists of 320 pages and is available in paperback format.
The term civil disobedience was coined by henry david thoreau in his. Thoreaus disgust with the institution of slavery was one of his primary motives in writing civil disobedience. The ld file civil disobedience moral conviction that a certain law is immoral, or unjust. The ability of nonviolent civil disobedience and resulting criminal trials to strengthen democratic and constitutional values and institutions is well. Hegeler, the monist is one of the worlds oldest and most important journals in philosophy.
Civil disobedience definition of civil disobedience by. The carl cohen collection papers, 19661974 predominantly, 19711974 5. In his insightful critique of hannah arendts political philosophy, george kateb expresses surprise at her inclination to affirm, even celebrate, the phenomenon of civil disobedience. The second section delineates her debts to montesquieu in this regard. Carl cohen, law, speech and disobedience in civil disobedience, ed. An act of civil disobedience is an illegal public protest, nonviolent in character. Civil disobedience and bioethics by carl cohen a morally right act is one that ought to be done. Civil disobedience definition is refusal to obey governmental demands or commands especially as a nonviolent and usually collective means of forcing concessions from the government. It is a phony government, because it is only a government in the minds of the people.
When university administrators sought to censor the showing of sexually explicit films on campus, cohen, then serving as chair of the university faculty, strongly defended student freedoms before the regents of the university, with ultimate success. Pdf civil disobedience, punishment, and injustice candice. Section 2 is devoted to the main objections against, and theorists defenses of, civil disobedience. According to current definitions of civil disobedience, drawn from the work of john rawls and carl cohen, ecosaboteurs are not civil disobedients because their disobedience is. Proponents of civil disobedience defended their breaking of law on the basis that christians must obey. Unfortunately, the authorities often do not think how the adopted laws will affect the ordinary peoples lives and to which consequences this can lead. Racial discrimination in varying forms was opposed on the grounds that it was immoral, and sit ins were deliberate, peaceful, and public violation of laws. Conscience, tactics, and the law university of michigan faculty reprints. John stuart mill once said that all political philo sophers are oneeyed men. Governments show thus how successfully men can be imposed on, even impose on themselves, for their own advantage. He graduated summa cum laude in 1951 from the university. Medical school and the residential college, the university of michigan, ann arbor, mi. Conscience, tactics, and the law university of michigan faculty reprints carl cohen on.
The first section argues that arendt is a socalled agonistic constitutionalist. According to current definitions of civil disobedience, drawn from the work of john rawls and carl cohen, ecosaboteurs are not civil disobedients because their disobedience is not a form of address andor does not appeal to the publics sense of justice or human welfare. The main characters of this classics, philosophy story are. His nine books, translated into many languages, include. In citing the war, he was simply taking advantage of the fact that the war was a particularly unpopular one in the north. Created by the original team behind sparknotes, litcharts are the worlds best literature guides. Cohen, a university of michigan philosopher, posits that every citizen has a prima facie duty to obey the nations laws. The christian and civil disobedience truth magazine. Cyber civil disobedience a frontier of legal and ethical challenges doug himberger, ph. Defending civil disobedience the monist oxford academic. On rawls and civil disobedience, see sabl, andrew, looking forward to justice. However, it did not explode until the final phase of the reign of dr. He is best known for his book walden, which reflects on the value of living simply and in accord with nature. Rawlsian civil disobedience and its nonrawlsian lessons, journal of political philosophy, 9 2001, pp.
Christian bay, john rawls, rex martin, joseph betz, w. This chapter explores the place of civil disobedience in hannah arendts work to generate an account of constitutionalism in which the rule of law and democracy are mutually constitutive rather than opposed principles. Read moral judgment, historical reality, and civil disobedience, philosophy and public affairs on deepdyve, the largest online rental service for scholarly research with thousands of academic publications available at your fingertips. Civil disobedience by carl cohen, 9780231086462, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. This book is a philosophical exploration of all aspects of civil disobedience, and an inquiry into the circumstances in which it. Motto in civil disobedience, thoreau society bulletin, 67. Henry david thoreau was born on july 12, 1817 in concord massachusetts, to john thoreau, a. Welcome to the litcharts study guide on henry david thoreaus civil disobedience. This paper is in response to hannah arendts views on civil disobedience. The first edition of the novel was published in 1854, and was written by henry david thoreau.
According to current definitions of civil disobedience, drawn from the work of john rawls and carl cohen, ecosaboteurs are not civil disobedients because their disobedience is not a form of. Carl cohen and were opened for research in carl cohen was born in 1931. Henry david thoreau 18171862 was an american author, poet, philosopher, abolitionist, and naturalist. It has been going on since the days of tunku abdul rahman. Civil disobedience is conduct that obliges us to think about our obligation to obey the law about the ground of that obligation, and the force of it. The war with mexico was not declared until 1846, whereas thoreau had refused to pay his tax as early as 1843. To get back to the founding principles, as articulated in the declaration of independence, zinn argues that we are going to need to go outside the law, to stop obeying the laws that demand killing or that allocate wealth the way it has been done, or. A classic framework cohen 1966 framework component. Defending civil disobedience, the monist, volume 54, issue 4, 1 october 1970, pages 469487. Cohen argues that thoreaus action is not civil disobedience in the strict. Moral judgment, historical reality, and civil disobedience. On the duty of civil disobedience1 abridged henry david thoreau i heartily accept the motto,that government is best which governs least. Some philosophical assessments of environmental disobedience.
156 409 1128 1010 1117 632 672 1085 748 1328 1032 1504 462 472 1003 1363 688 1190 751 965 478 1034 408 482 602 821 1234 793 900 617 1130 794 911 724 1379 818 645 804 612 795